A few weeks ago we posted a little primer on R-value and how understanding it can help you make intelligent value choices for your home. (If you missed it and aren’t sure what R-value is, take a minute and read What the Heck is R-Value, Anyway?)
Now we’re going to tell you why R-value is overrated.
Heat flow vs. air flow
When it comes to keeping your home comfortable, there are three “flow systems” you need to be aware of: air flow, heat flow and moisture flow. A material’s R-value, or resistance to heat, only applies to one of them. (I think you can guess which one!)
The problem with rating an insulating material only according to R-value is that heat flow is only part of the picture. One of the major ways you lose energy is because of air flow – all the little cracks and gaps and crevices in your walls. Preventing heat from escaping is good, but you also want to make sure your walls aren’t allowing air to flow through them.
That’s one of the issues with fiberglass insulation. It’s light and fluffy and air flows right through it. If your home is tight it may not be an issue, but if you have cracks and fissures in your building envelope you’ll feel it in the form of drafts and higher energy bills.
Board insulation and foam insulation (like any of the expanding foams on the market or non-expanding foam like Insulsmart), on the other hand, let virtually no air through. Try this experiment: take a piece of cotton or polyester stuffing and hold it to your mouth. Now plug your nose and breathe. No problem, right? (Don’t do this with real fiberglass unless you really enjoy irritated skin.)
Now, do the same thing with a hunk of Styrofoam and see how fast you turn blue. Which do you think makes better draft protection?
Funny Numbers
The other problem with R-value is one of temperature. R-value testing on insulation is done at – get this – 75°F. With no air flow.
Now who needs insulation when it’s 75 degrees out? I don’t know about you, but at 75 degrees I’m opening my windows and enjoying the breeze. Insulation? Who needs it?
Insulation only matters when there’s an appreciable difference in temperature between what Mother Nature wants to throw at us and where we have our thermostat set.
If materials behaved the same regardless of temperature it wouldn’t matter. But they don’t. Some materials actually perform better as the temperature drops.
And some perform worse. Way worse.
Let’s pick on fiberglass again. Fiberglass is usually rated at about R-3.1 or so per inch. Not too bad, considering how cheap it is. But did you know that the R-value of fiberglass can shrink by as much as 50% when temperatures dip below zero? Its effectiveness tanks like a rock when it gets cold. In subzero temperatures, fiberglass is only half again better per inch than plywood sheathing. (Or worse – at least wood doesn’t settle and makes a pretty decent air barrier.)
In contrast, some materials work harder for you as the temperature drops. For instance, Insulsmart improves from R-4.6 at 75° to a toasty R-5.1 at 25°.
Need to insulate your home?
If you’re thinking of insulating your home don’t be fooled by funny numbers. Make sure you know the whole story about the product you install. A more expensive product often turns out to be the best value in the long run.
What’s your experience?
To find out more about how you can take charge of your home energy profile, visit us at http://www.Performanceenergyinc.com/.